Two Types of there-sentences and Feature Specification

Chorong Kang 1 ,
Author Information & Copyright
1Seoul National University
*Corresponding Author : Lecturer, Department of Linguistics Seoul National University Building 5-308, 1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-Gu, Seoul 08826, Korea, E-mail:

ⓒ Copyright 2019 Language Education Institute, Seoul National University. This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: Mar 04, 2019 ; Revised: Jul 02, 2019 ; Accepted: Jul 30, 2019

Published Online: Aug 31, 2019


This paper aimed to account for unexpected accusative case on a pronominal associate in there-sentences (there was him). It is unexpected that under the long-standing assumption in generative grammar, agreement coincides with case assignment. Since there-associates appear to agree with T in number (e.g. there was/*were a dog), they are expected to be valued as nominative case. Furthermore, such a pronominal associate with accusative case is not available in there-V type sentences (*there arrived him). In this paper, I propose a multiple-there hypothesis to account for different behaviors of there-V and there-BE. In the proposal, I argue that there-s in there-V and there-BE are base-generated in different positions due to their different “grammatical roles” (semantically null expletive vs. subject argument). Based on the distinction, I further argue that there-s have different feature specifications and show that the proposed system captures different behaviors between there-sentences with respect to sub-extraction and control.

Keywords: there-sentences; feature specification; pronominal associate; long-distance agreement; accusative case



Bowers, John. (1993). The syntax of predication. Linguistic Inquiry 24,591-656 .


Beyssade, Claire. and Carmen Dobrovie-Sorin. (2005). A syntax-based analysis of predication. In E. Georgala and J. Howell, eds., Proceedings of Semantics and Linguistic Theory XV. Ithaca, New York: CLC Publications .


Belletti, Adriana and Luigi Rizzi. (1988). Psych-Verbs and θ-Theory. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 6, 291-352 .


Bolinger, Dwight. (1977). Meaning and Form. London: Longman .


Borschev, Vladimir and Barbara H. Partee. (1998). Bytijnye predloženija i otricanie v russkom jazyke: semantika i kommunikativnaja struktura. [Existential sentences and negation in Russian: semantics and communicative structure]. In A. S. Narin'yani, ed., Dialogue '98: Computational Linguistics and Its Applications, 173-182. Kazan: Xéter .


Borschev, Vladimir, and Barbara H. Partee. (2001). The Russian genitive of negation in existential sentences: The role of theme-rheme structure reconsidered. Ms., University of Massachusetts, Amherst. In Travaux du Cercle Linguistique de Prague (nouvelle serie), v. 4, ed. by Eva Hajiekova and Petr Sgall. Amsterdam: John Benjamins .


Burzio, Luigi. (1986). Italian Syntax. Dordrecht .


Chomsky, Noam. (1995). The Minimalist Program. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .


Chomsky, Noam. (2000). Minimalist inquiries: The framework. In R. Martin, D. Michaels & J. Uriagereka, eds., Step by Step: Essays on Minimalist Syntax in Honor of Howard Lasnik, 89-155. Cambridge: MIT Press .


Chomsky, Noam. (2001). Derivation by phase. In M. Kenstowicz, ed., Ken Hale: A Life in Language, 1-52. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .


Deal, Amy, R. (2009). The origin and content of expletives: Evidence from ''Selection''. Syntax 12, 285-323 .


Diesing, Molly. (1992). Indefinites. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .


Emonds, Joseph E. (1985). A Unified Theory of Syntactic Categories. Dordrecht: Foris .


Francez, Itamar. (2006). Semantic structure and argument realization in (mostly Hebrew) existentials. In Y. Falk, ed., Proceedings of Israel Association for Theoretical Linguistics 22, Retrieved from .


Harley, Heidi. (1995). Abstracting away from abstract case. Proceedings of NELS 25. GLSA, University of Massachusetts .


Hartmann, Jutta M. (2005). Wh-movement and the Small Clause Analyses of the English there-construction. Leiden Papers in Linguistics, 2, 93-106 .


Hartmann, Jutta M. (2008). Expletives in Existentials. English there and German da. Ph.D. dissertation. Tilburg .


Hazout, Ilan. (2004). The syntax of existential constructions. Linguistic Inquiry 35, 393-430 .


Hoekstra, Teun, and Rene Mulder. (1990). Unergatives as copular verbs: Locational and existential predication. The Linguistic Review 7, 1-79 .


Kallulli, Dalina. (2008). There Is secondary predication in There-Existentials. In Charles B. Chang and Hannah J. Haynie, ed., Proceedings of the 26th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 279-287. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Proceedings Project .


Kratzer, Angelika. (2005). Building resultatives. In C. Maienborn & A. Wöllstein, eds., Event Arguments: Foundations and Applications, 177-212. Tübingen: Max Niemeyer Verlag .


Laka, Itziar. (2000). Theta blind Case: Burzio's Generalization and its image in the mirror. arguments and case. In E. Reuland, ed., Explaining Burzio's Generalization, 103-129. Amsterdam: John Benjamins .


Landau, Idan. (2007). EPP Extensions. Linguistic Inquiry, 38, 485-523 .


Legate, Julie. (2003). Some interface properties of the phase, Linguistic Inquiry 34, 506-516 .


Martinez Insua, Ana E., and Ignacio M. Palacios Martinez. (2003). A corpus-based approach to non-concord in present-day English existential there- constructions. English Studies 84 (3), 262-83 .


McNally, Louise. (1997). A Semantics for the English Existential Construction. New York: Garland .


Milsark, Gary, L. (1974). Existential Sentences in English. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT .


Moro, Andrea. (1991). The raising of predicates: Copula, expletives, and existence. In Lisa L.S. Cheng and Hamid Demirdache, ed., More Papers on Wh-movement, MIT Working Papers in Linguistics. Cambridge, MA: MIT .


Moro, Andrea. (1997). The Raising of Predicates. Predicative Noun Phrases and the Theory of Clause Structure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .


Moro, Andrea. (2000). Dynamic Antisymmetry. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press .


Muss-Arnolt, W. (1894). The chaldean account of the deluge. The Biblical World 3 109-118 .


Platzack, C. 1983. Existential sentences in English, German, Icelandic, and Swedish. In F. Karlsson, ed., Papers from the 7th Scandinavian Conference on Linguistics, 80-100. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, Department of General Linguistics .


Pylkkänen, Liina. (2002). Introducing Arguments. Ph.D. dissertation. MIT .


Rando, Emily, and Donna Jo Napoli. (1978). Defnites in there-sentences. Language 54, 300-313 .


Richards, M. & T. Biberauer. (2005). Explaining Expl. In M. den Dikken & C. Tortora, eds., The Function Of Function Words And Functional Categories, 115-153. Amsterdam: John Benjamins .


Sabel, Joachim. (2000). Expletives as Features, in R. Billerey et al. (eds.) WCCFL 19 Proceedings, Cascadilla Press, Somerville, MA, 411-424 .


Schütze, Carson. T. (2001). On the nature of default case. Syntax 4, 205-238 .


Schäfer, Florian. 2013. Reconciling Burzio's generalization with unexpected accusatives: from German to Icelandic, talk presented at the 28th Comparative Germanic Syntax Workshop, Leipzig .


Schütze, Carson T. (2002) On the nature of default case. Syntax 4(3), 205-238 .


Sigurðsson, Halldór A. (2000). The locus of case and agreement. The locus of case and agreement. Working Papers in Scandinavian Syntax 65, 65-108 .


Sigurðsson, Halldór A. (2003). Case: abstract vs. morphological. In Ellen Brandner, and Heike Zinsmeister, eds., New Perspectives on Case Theory, 223-268. Stanford: CSLI Publications .


Sigurðsson, Halldór A. (2009). The no case generalization. In A. Alexiadou et al. eds., Advances in Comparative Germanic Syntax, 249-280. Amsterdam: John Benjamins .


Stowell, Tim. (1978). What was there before there was there. In Donka Farkas, ed., Proceedings of the 13th Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistics Society, 458-471. Chicago: CLS .


Surányi Balázs. (2009). Subject islands: Cyclicity of derivation and intermediate movement to edges. NELS 38 (Proceedings of 38th Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society). Amherst: GLSA. 401-414 .


Tsunoda, Tasaku. (1981). Split case-marking patterns in verb-types and tense/aspect/mood. Linguistics 19, 389-438 .


Travis, Lisa. (1984). Parameters and Effects of Word Order Variation. Ph.D. dissertation. MIT .


Williams, Edwin. (1994). Thematic Structure in Syntax. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press .